S&W 4506, 4006 and 6906: Police Trade-In Pistols Compared
Last updated 23 October 2026.
The short answer
Smith & Wesson's third-generation pistols came in several sizes and calibers, and many police agencies carried them. The 4506 is the .45 ACP full-size, the 4006 is the .40 S&W with a 4-inch barrel, and the 6906 is the compact 9mm. The 9mm 5906 is the one most people compare them with.
Side by side
| 4506 | 4006 | 6906 | 5906 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caliber | .45 ACP | .40 S&W | 9mm | 9mm |
| Barrel | 5 in. | 4 in. | 3.5 in. | 4 in. |
| Magazine | 8 rounds (+1) | 11 rounds | 10 or 12 (sources differ) | 15 (10-round option) |
| Built | 1988 to 1999 | 1990 to 2011 | 1989 to 1999 | 1989 to 1999 |
| Size | Full-size | Mid-size | Compact | Full-size |
Figures come from Wikipedia (4506), Wikipedia (4006) and the Internet Movie Firearms Database (6906). Sources disagree on a few numbers, so check the exact pistol in front of you.
Which to pick
- 4506: if you want .45 ACP and a heavy, steady full-size gun.
- 4006: if you want the .40 S&W with a lighter, shorter barrel.
- 6906: if you want a smaller 9mm for carry. It has an aluminum frame with a stainless slide.
- 5906: the all-stainless 9mm; see our 5903 vs 5906 vs 5946 guide.
Buying a used one
These are older guns, so used police trade-ins are usually single units and listings can sell out. Check the bore, the slide and decocker action, and ask what magazines come with it. A pistol is a complete firearm, so it ships to a licensed dealer (FFL) in your state, where you complete the paperwork and background check.
General information, not legal advice. Current as of September 2026. Laws change; check the official source before you act.







