S&W 5903 vs 5906 vs 5946: What's the Difference?
Last updated 21 October 2026.
The short answer
These three Smith & Wesson third-generation 9mm pistols look almost the same. The 5906 is all stainless steel. The 5903 has a lighter aluminum-alloy frame under a stainless slide. The 5946 is stainless like the 5906 but is double-action only, with no safety levers. If you shoot a pistol with a manual safety or decocker, the 5906 is the one most people mean; the 5946 trades that for a long, consistent trigger pull.
Side by side
| 5906 | 5903 | 5946 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frame | Stainless steel | Aluminum alloy | Stainless steel |
| Slide | Stainless steel | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
| Action | Double/single-action | Double/single-action | Double-action only |
| Safety levers | Yes, ambidextrous safety/decocker | Yes | None |
| Magazine | 15 rounds (10-round option) | 15 rounds | Same family |
| 5906 weight | About 38 oz (1,070 g); the aluminum 5903 is lighter. Sources differ slightly on exact weights. | ||
Production dates are quoted differently by different sources. Wikipedia lists the 5906 at 1989 to 1999, the 5903 at about 1990 to 1997, and the 5946 at 1990 to 1999.
Who used them
According to Wikipedia, former 5906 users include the Los Angeles, Colorado Springs and Honolulu police departments and the Puerto Rico Police (1990 to 2010). The 5946 was used by the RCMP and the NYPD, and the Royal Bahamas Defence Force and Japan Coast Guard are listed as current users of S&W pistols from this family.
Which one to pick
- 5906: the most common police trade-in. Heaviest, and the steadiest to shoot.
- 5903: same layout, less weight on the belt thanks to the aluminum frame.
- 5946: best if you want no safety to manage and a trigger that feels the same every shot.
Read our 5906 trade-in guide for what to check on a used one. A pistol is a complete firearm, so it ships to a licensed dealer (FFL) in your state, where you complete the paperwork and background check.
General information, not legal advice. Current as of September 2026. Laws change; check the official source before you act.







